DPE-2026-0002

Weigeren zonder effect

Weigeren verandert niet wat de browser verlaat.

Familie
Toestemming
Status
actief
Geldt voor
web

Wat er gebeurt

The site asks for consent and registers the refusal, but the tags that the refusal should stop do not sit behind the gate. The screen confirms the choice; the wire shows the same traffic as before.

Waarom het ertoe doet

A refusal that changes nothing makes the right to withhold and to withdraw consent a formality. The visitor believes they have decided something and they have not.

Veelvoorkomende oorzaken

  • tags hardcoded rather than gated
  • consent tool blocks cookies but not the loading of scripts or containers
  • banner is informational and wired to nothing

Dit is het níet

If nothing was asked before the tag fired, that is Tracking before consent. If no refusal option is offered at all, that is No refusal option.

Hoe je het vaststelt

Indicator

Set comparison: the third-party hosts contacted after an explicitly registered refusal are equal to, or a superset of, those contacted without any interaction. There is no third reading.

Methode

differential

Kwaliteit van de detectie

97 van 100

De grenzen van deze bevinding

Wat dit patroon zou weerleggen

  • The refusal was not registered.machinaal te toetsende bevinding vervaltThe most important one: it turns a finding into a measurement error.
  • The banner does block, but later than the capture window.machinaal te toetsende bevinding vervalt
  • The surviving requests are strictly necessary for a service the visitor asked for.niet uit de meting af te leidende bevinding krijgt een ander patroonA judgement per host. Never excluded automatically; an entry may be cited with this untested as long as that is stated.

Wat dit patroon níet vaststelt

  • harm; the catalogue standardises a finding so it can be referred to, it does not weigh it
  • severity; there is no score here, by design. Weighing belongs to whoever applies the entry to a concrete case
  • unlawfulness; that is for a supervisory authority or a court
  • intent; a fault is usually a build decision, not a plan
  • absence: not finding it in one capture is not evidence that it is not there

Reproduceren

  • manualMETHOD.mdno dedicated reproduction exists yet; follow the general method and the indicator above
  • scriptrepro/web/check.mjsthe run reports DPE-2026-0002 as present, with the detail behind it

Ook zichtbaar met openbare scanners

urlscan.iowebbkoll

Juridisch kader

Bepalingen

eu-gdpr-6-1-anl-tw-11-7a

Rechtspraak

cjeu-planet49

Veelgehoorde tegenwerpingen

The banner is there, so the visitor has a choice.

The choice exists on screen and not on the wire. Consent requires an active act of the user; an act without effect is not such an act.

This is analytics, which needs no consent.

Then the banner should not have listed it, and there would be no refusal to honour. A party cannot both treat something as consent-bound and ignore the refusal.

Geldt wanneer

to-processing

Aangetroffen in

De onderzoeken waarin dit patroon gemeten is.

Verwante patronen

← alle patronen