Invoer wordt standaard trainingsmateriaal
Wat iemand in een dienst typt, wordt bewaard om een model te verbeteren, tenzij hij een instelling vindt en uitzet.
- Familie
- Gegevens
- Status
- actief
- Geldt voor
- web, mobile-app, api, desktop
Wat er gebeurt
A service accepts text, images or files in order to answer, and keeps them afterwards for a second purpose: improving a model, evaluating quality, or review by people. A control that prevents it exists, but it stands at on when the account is created, sits several steps from the input screen, applies only to what is submitted after it is changed, or is offered on a paid tier only. At the moment of typing the person is told nothing about the second purpose.
Waarom het ertoe doet
People put things into these services that they put nowhere else: a draft resignation, a medical letter, a client file, a message about a family member. Kept as training material, that content leaves the person's reach altogether. It cannot be found back, cannot be corrected, and cannot be removed from what has been built on it.
Veelvoorkomende oorzaken
- retention for improvement on by default, with an opt-out per account
- a business tier excluded from training while the free tier is not, without that being visible at the moment of typing
- review by people described as a security measure rather than as a second purpose
- an application built on another party's model, passing content on under that party's default terms
Dit is het níet
Content reaching an advertising or measurement party is User input to third parties, where the content is a by-product. Here it is the payload, and the fault is the second use of it. A store that writes the payload into a log is Logs recording content, not events, which is about the operator's own housekeeping rather than a second purpose.
Hoe je het vaststelt
Indicator
In an account created for the test and left untouched, the control governing use of input for model improvement or review by people stands at on, and the terms of the same date state that submitted content is used for that purpose. Both are read as delivered, before anything is changed.
Methode
document-comparison
Kwaliteit van de detectie
90 van 100
De grenzen van deze bevinding
Wat dit patroon zou weerleggen
- The default stands at off and the person has to switch it on.met de hand te toetsende bevinding vervalt
- Submitted content is used to produce the answer and is destroyed within a stated short period.met de hand te toetsende bevinding vervalt
- Switching the control off also removes what was submitted before.met de hand te toetsende bevinding wordt zwakker
- The operator does not retain it; the content is passed to another party under that party's terms.met de hand te toetsende bevinding krijgt een ander patroonThe recipient is then the party to address, and the operator's silence about it is a transparency finding.
Wat dit patroon níet vaststelt
- harm; the catalogue standardises a finding so it can be referred to, it does not weigh it
- severity; there is no score here, by design. Weighing belongs to whoever applies the entry to a concrete case
- unlawfulness; that is for a supervisory authority or a court
- intent; a fault is usually a build decision, not a plan
- absence: not finding it in one capture is not evidence that it is not there
Reproduceren
- manual
METHOD.mdno dedicated reproduction exists yet; follow the general method and the indicator above
Juridisch kader
Bepalingen
Veelgehoorde tegenwerpingen
It is in the terms.
A second purpose has to be clear at the moment of typing, and the default has to be the protective one. A term accepted once at sign-up is not a choice per submission.
The data is anonymised before training.
Free text is not anonymised by removing a name; it identifies through its content. And what is being examined is what is retained, not what may be filtered later.
You can switch it off.
The finding is the default, not the possibility. A control that has to be found is a control most people never reach.
Reviewers only see fragments.
A fragment of a medical letter is a medical letter. The unit of review does not change the category of the content.
Geldt wanneer
to-processing